Looking west from 21 Main St., 1977
(Westchester Co. Historical Society)
_____
A Short
History of
Main Street,
Tarrytown NY(Its North Side)
_____
This written material on this site
has been borrowed from the book
G. Washington Slept Here:
A Sleepy Hollow Local History.
Copyright ©2021 Notary Sojak.
All Rights Reserved.
A free sample (including all of
Main St.) may be downloaded
HERE .
Cramer-McCutcheon Hardware_Alma Snape Flowers
_____
A Featured Spot
_____A Featured Spot
_____.A Featured Spot
_____.A Featured Spot
_____.A Featured Spot
_____
A Featured Spot
_____Pincus Ice Cream______Arduino's Off-Broadway
____
A Featured Spot
_____Two Feature Films
(View two short clips.)(Google Street View)
_____Touch or click on each link below:
yolasite.com/Pinkys.php
&
Setbackinn.webnode.com
_____A Featured Spot
_____
A Featured Spot
_____
A Featured Spot
_____Galella's Barber Shop______John Charles, Ltd.
_____Two Feature Films
(View two short clips.)
(A still-frame from the first movie listed below)
_____Touch or click on each link below:
yolasite.com/A-Night-at-the-Music-Hall.php
&
yolasite.com/Music-Hall-and-then-Set-Back
_____
A Featured Spot
_____A Featured Spot
_____
A Featured Spot
__________Favorite Places,
Well-Remembered:
__________
This store & its neighbor--an
eatery--were once featured in a
NY Times article. Read it here:
_____
_____
_____(Tarrytown & Sleepy Hollow in the 20th Century, p. 80.)
_____
_____
_____
All red-tint photos are scanned from the 1970
Tarrytown Centennial booklet. Due to the use of
very pale (red) ink, these photos must be
processed heavily here, to be clearly visible.
_____
Please visit one of our other
websites. The first is a short
history of Main St., Tarrytown
(its south side):
bn89.webnode.page
_____
The next highlights the Classic
NY State Historic Site Markers
in the Tarrytown/SH NY area:
classicnystatehistoricsitemarkerstarrytownsharea.mystrikingly.com
_____
Then, our list of SHHS teach-
ers and other local notables
whom we pay tribute to on
their respective birthdays:
notabletarrytownersbirthdayswikipediahsteachers.mystrikingly.com
_____
Next, enjoy classic Ameri-
cana photos shot by Life
Magazine contributor
Eliot Elisofon in the Tarry-
towns in 1943. No record
remains of publication.
tarrytownasseenbyeliotelisofon.jimdofree.com
_____
Then, a short history of
Beekman Ave., Sleepy
Hollow (its south side):
ba45.webnode.page_____
Next, a short history of the
1st part of No. Broadway,
Tarrytown (its west side):
historynobroadwaywestsidetarrytown.mystrikingly.com
_____
Last, some short clips from
feature films that were shot
in the area of Tarrytown/SH:
tarrytowninmovies.yolasite.com/Film-Friday.php
_____
We don't own any of these photos, nor any
of the films/photos that we link to. They are
being displayed here under the doctrine of
Fair Use; for educational purposes, only._____
61 Main St.
Isabel's Cafe
_____(Westchester Co. Historical Society)
1984
_____
The quite-stylish "Isabel's Cafe" appeared
on the scene a bit later than a lot of my
Main St. favorites. It quickly became known
for its ceiling (plastered with old sheets of
newspaper--as visible in the photo just below);
also, such unusual food combinations as
eggplant pizza; and particularly, its barmaids.
After its initial heyday in the 1980s, Isabel's
experienced at least one change in
management, being run by the well-liked
villager Mike Hyland at one point. But our
cafe managed to keep its same name until
much later: when it began featuring Italian
food, it became known as "Isabella's Bistro." It
finally folded--after a respectable run of over
30 years. Until recently, a restaurant named
the "Twisted Oak" (see bottom photo) was
occupying this storefront.
_____
(Westchester Co. Historical Society)
1981
_____
From my perspective--never having been
inside, myself--Isabel's timeline seems
to mirror the more general transition of
Main St.: from family-owned, closely-
monitored storefronts; to more trendy
establishments that seem like they could
have been designed by a think tank! Isabel's
was, indeed, locally-owned--at least at its
inception--and certainly, Main St. benefited
from its Greenwich-Village-type appeal,
unusual at the time for the tri-village area.
It was a place where William Burroughs and
Allen Ginsburg, if visiting Tarrytown, might
have blended in--unnoticed. Looking at these
photos, it makes me a bit sad that my time
in town was never in sync to its time.
_____(Google Street View)_____The written material on this site
has been borrowed from the book
G. Washington Slept Here:
A Sleepy Hollow Local History.
Copyright ©2021 Notary Sojak.
All Rights Reserved.
A free sample (including all of
Main St.) may be downloaded
HERE .9 Main St.
Music Hall Bldg.
_____Leventhal's
(Google Street View)
_____
If one is moving west along the north side of
Main St., #9 is the first storefront beyond
the Washington Building; being located, rather,
within the classic theater structure of the
"Music Hall." Hosting the newspaper and candy
store "Leventhal's" in the 1960s, 9 Main St.
today houses "iFix4u," a computer & phone
repair place (above). In between, among other
uses, it served as an antique store (bottom
photo). Leventhal's mustn't be confused with
either of the Levitan's (one was on South
Broadway, and another, on Orchard St.).
_____
A lot of kids did not even know of it as
Leventhal's, as it seemed like a member of the
Murray Frank family was always on-duty
there. In fact, many townies today remember it
as an early version of "Murray Frank's," the
stationery store which, later in the 1960s,
opened for business at the north corner of
Central Ave. and North Broadway. Due to its
location, Leventhal's mission centered on
outfitting kids for the Saturday matinees.
_____
_____
But there were no jumbo, theater-style candy
packages, to entice us to pay more for just a
few extra pieces. Plus--somehow--candy back
then just tasted better, compared to what one
might buy inside a theater today. (It must have
been that pure cane sugar!) On weekdays, I can
attest that it was also an excellent outlet for
such things as comic books and baseball cards.
Actually, we boys (and probably a few girls)
were buying packages of bubble gum, which
then included the sports cards.
_____
A personal note: Mrs. Frank would
save--for me, exclusively--the cardboard
containers out of which the baseball card
packets were sold. These made excellent (&
unique) card containers at home. So let's
"give it up" for the Frank family!
_____
(Westchester Co. Historical Society)
As antique store, 1989
_____
The written material on this site
has been borrowed from the book
G. Washington Slept Here:
A Sleepy Hollow Local History.
Copyright ©2021 Notary Sojak.
All Rights Reserved.
A free sample (including all of
Main St.) may be downloaded
HERE ._____
Back to Home
To Sleepy Hollow '70s
_____
21 Main St.
Kelbro
Discount
Center
(formerly Reynold's
Hardware)
_____(Westchester Co. Historical Society)
27 Main St.
Motecatini
Pizzeria/
Restaurant
(formerly Johnny's)_____(Westchester Co. Historical Society)
29 Main St.
Mory's Army
And Navy
(formerly
Flockhart's)
_____(Westchester Co. Historical Society)
1976
_____
At the time of Urban Renewal, "Mory's
Army & Navy" moved to Main St. from
Orchard St. (see photo above, 29 Main, a
long-term location of the store). The heal-
thy Orchard St. ("Underhill") rivalry between
A. & N. stores continued as "Shubert's Army
& Navy" relocated about a block away--19
Main. Later, Mory's founding owner--Mory
Silverman (pictured just below)--sold his
business to Mike Janos (bottom photo) and
Mark Longhi--all three being, I believe,
residents of Irvington (our next village
south, of course).
_____
_____
Early on, long before the arrival of Mory's,
the building housed "Nann's Hat Store"; dur-
ing that era, it also served as a courtroom,
as well as a voting room. For many years
after that, it hosted "Flockhart's" (which sold
fabrics & women's clothing). One point remains
a bit of a mystery: after Urban Renewal had
commenced, but before Flockhart's had to shut
its doors, where on Main was Mory's doing
business?
_____
Both stores ran ads in the 1970 Tarrytown
Centennial booklet. Unfortunately, only street
names were listed for participating businesses
(there being no mention of street #). There is,
indeed, at least one photo posted on the internet
showing a Mory's awning installed at 35 Main
St. However, no such local has yet surfaced: one
who was paying attention to such details--circa
1970--and who remembers Mory's actually
being in business at that location.
_____
_____
.After the move from Orchard St., Mory's
remained a vital business on Main St. for more
than 20 years (while Shubert's, after a number
of years on Main, reportedly moved its store to
Port Chester, N.Y.). Some of the brand names
stocked at Mory’s? Converse All-Stars, Dr. J's,
Lee's, Levi's, Nike, Pro-Keds, and Sweet Ors.
Also, a tee-shirt press was kept busy, shirts
being created--to order.
_____
Perhaps Mory’s reached its peak years during
the final, Janos-only period of ownership.
Reading published comments on the internet
(which seem to pertain mostly to these final
years), I find myself concluding that Mory's
had to have been one of the most beloved area
stores--ever (and we sure loved lots of them!).
_____
(Westchester Co. Historical Society)
1991
_____
The written material on this site
has been borrowed from the book
G. Washington Slept Here:
A Sleepy Hollow Local History.
Copyright ©2021 Notary Sojak.
All Rights Reserved.
A free sample (including all of
Main St.) may be downloaded
HERE ._____
Back to Home
_____
33 Main St.
Set Back Inn
_____(Westchester Co. Historical Society)
1976
_____
The "Set Back Inn" opened in 1959, and it
is--in fact--still in business. Along with the
“Music Hall” theater, this popular tavern is
one of a very few Main St. establishments
that have stood the test of time. And like
the Music Hall, it has been used at times
by feature-film directors--including
Robert DeNiro--as a shooting location.
_____
When Hollywood scouts have called, the
tavern keepers have observed both of these
extreme reactions: the scouts love the interior,
but want to redecorate it (often, to reflect a
different time period); or, they don't want to
touch a thing, because they like the local
“vibe.” As for its name, the front entrance is
literally set-back-in; that is, away from
the sidewalk.
_____
Pictured below (in 1970) are the founding
proprietors, Gus and Olga Toth. Three
generations of the Toth family have
steered the tavern through six decades of
inflation, "stagflation," recession, and--most
recently--pandemic (although, in between,
there have been lots of good years!).
_____
Many such small businesses--in both
villages--sponsored softball teams, the sports
rivalries often just as significant as the
primary store function. Among those who ran
such businesses in the Tarrytowns in the 20th
century, sometimes it paid off--not to change.
Reportedly, the Set Back is still cash-only!
_____
_____
The written material on this site
has been borrowed from the book
G. Washington Slept Here:
A Sleepy Hollow Local History.
Copyright ©2021 Notary Sojak.
All Rights Reserved.
A free sample (including all of
Main St.) may be downloaded
HERE ._____
Back to Home
_____
5 Main St.
Washington Bldg.
_____Santa Fe
Restaurant
(formerly Tim Clune's aka
The Broadway Tavern)
_____(Westchester Co. Historical Society)
1986
_____
The pharmacy “Russell & Lawrie's” was
precisely on the corner of North Broadway
& Main St. As late as the 1960s, it still
touted its proprietors as "Druggists &
Chemists" on its outdoor signage; but alas,
Messrs. Russell and Lawrie were already
long-gone. This rather large corner
building, named after George Washington,
incorporated the very spot where he had
once rested (albeit, in a previous structure).
If heading down Main St. in my era, the
next shop (#3) was a haberdasher: “John
Charles, Ltd.” (just below, with the
striped awning); then came #5--"Tim
Clune's"--aka “The Broadway Tavern.”
_____
_____
About all seen of Clune's just above is his BT
sign, which was one of the few allowed to
extend out--over the Main St. sidewalk--at a
right angle. Upon entering, one of the arcade
games would often enough be heard in the
background. Based around bowling (below,
making use of a flat puck, rather than a
ball), its bell would ring up strikes and
spares--even the occasional perfect game of
300! Originally, Tim Clune's had been at 2
North Broadway, which might explain how
Broadway ended up a permanent part of his
tavern's name (with the Arduinos--at 25
Main--cleverly making use of the Manhattan
theatrical term Off-Broadway).
_____
_____
After the tavern ceased operations, “Blyer's
1894 Inn” took over this Main St. spot
(1894 being the modern building’s year of
construction). Jack Hulse, the manager of
'"Whelan Drugs'' (just across the street,
profiled on my Broadway web page), had
opened Blyer's a bit before his iconic
pharmacy finally closed its doors. Returning
now to the top photo, that BT sign was
once affixed just above the pictured alcove.
Also, we see that #5 still later became the
"Santa Fe Restaurant." Incidentally, I
really doubt that the block lettering
SANTA FE on the Washington Building
would have"passed code" back in the 1950s.
It looks more like a temporary sign one
might display during a construction mode.
_____
No. 5 was more recently occupied by the
"Oath Craft Beer Sanctuary," another
restaurant/pub. But what of Tim and his
crew? With "Ed the Chef" busy in back,
Tim would greet diners, while Henry Brophy
was working his magic at the bar (these
last two gentlemen pictured below, l. to r.).
Eddie was known for fried scallops, London
broil, &--I almost forgot--his liver and
onions! Back on “meatless Fridays,” you
didn’t want to overlook the fish specials
(reminds me of the school cafeteria
offerings back then). How about a
bowl of Clune’s grea clam chowder?
_____
_____
A native Irishman, Mr. Clune first settled
in America and the Tarrytowns while in
his twenties. As Tim opened his original
Broadway establishment in 1940, his run as
a local tavern keeper was close to 35
years. Peter Zegarelli, a long-time local,
recently waxed nostalgic: "Tim Clune's was
a quiet Irish bar/eatery; seving simple
food, well-done. A hamburger was a simple
burger on a bun--no frills. The french
fries were excellent; those and a beer
were about a 'buck-35,' as I recall. But
you had to behave in there!"
_____
Other old-timers have reported kids
demonstrating dance steps there, reciting
the "Apostles' Creed," or singing an Irish
song on St. Patrick's Day--sometimes,
while standing on the bar! Perhaps Tim's
traditional closing words on that landmark
day account for the fame of this expression
that all will likely recognize: ''The jig is
up.''
_____
(Google Street View)
_____
The written material on this site
has been borrowed from the book
G. Washington Slept Here:
A Sleepy Hollow Local History.
Copyright ©2021 Notary Sojak.
All Rights Reserved.
A free sample (including all of
Main St.) may be downloaded
HERE .39 Main St.
Alma Snape
Flowers
_____(Westchester Co. Historical Society)
1984_____Here, we salute that former local estab-
lishment those of us guys who went to the
Senior Prom patronized just that one time:
"Alma Snape Flowers." (Okay, most of us
went there way more than once; & no, I
didn't even go to the Prom--Susan Dey
from Fox Lane H.S. was busy--I wonder
if she would still take the raincheck?)
_____
The Irving Siebrecht Jr. family
purchased it from Alma Snape (the
individual) in 1963. Members of
the Siebrecht family then served as
proprietors for over 40 years. Prior to
becoming a flower shop, #39 had housed
''Day's Bakery.'' Its ovens had been built
below ground level, and actually still
extend out--under the sidewalk--even
as far as the area below the street.
_____
(On the right, Greg Fitzsimmons, another satisfied
Alma Snape's customer, on the way to his 1984
prom, complete with boutonniere; being paired
here with the author's would-be prom date.)
_____
While well-aware of the shop's fine
reputation, I couldn't quite fathom why
the Snape name had been retained. Irv
Siebrecht, a son of the owners (who
are pictured at bottom), eventually took
over the store’s management; so I called on
him to set me straight: “Our shop name
was unique,” Irv explained. “Back then, the
people in this town, everybody knew one
another--not like now. The Snape name
had such a good reputation, why change
it?”
_____
Although I am sure that Mme. Snape, in her
day, ran a quality establishment, why not
simply--"Siebrecht & Son"? Okay, I get it--Irv
was only age seven; and his brother, but
eleven--at the time their parents bought the
shop. Viva Alma Snape! For the record, the
building has by now been sold, and it presently
houses the "Canfin (Art) Gallery."..I only hope
that it includes a portrait of Alma!
_____
_____
All red-tint photos are scanned from the 1970
Tarrytown Centennial booklet. Due to its use of
very pale ink, these photos must be processed
heavily here to be clearly visible.
_____
The written material on this site
has been borrowed from the book
G. Washington Slept Here:
A Sleepy Hollow Local History.
Copyright ©2021 Notary Sojak.
All Rights Reserved.
A free sample (including all of
Main St.) may be downloaded
HERE ._____
Back to Home
_____
49 Main St.
Kugel Building
_____Albanese's Pizzeria
_____What I will call here the local "Wedge" War
went on predominantly in North Tarrytown
(now Sleepy Hollow). While there were some
excellent-tasting subs made in Tarrytown
(with all but "Subway" calling them wedges),
many agreed that the two heavy-hitters were
Italian delicatessens on Beekman Ave. in NT:
"Greene County" (which is examined more
fully on my Beekman Ave. web page) and
"Malandrino's." But helping to even things
out a bit, a friendly difference-of-opinion
developed in Tarrytown in the 1960s--as
to which pizzeria was the best.
_____The main contenders sat only about a block
apart: ''Johnny's,'' at 27 Main St., had an
avid following; as did "Albanese's," once
located at our present spot on Main--#49.
(Proprietors Dominic and Marge Albanese are
pictured at bottom). Its sign was one of a few
allowed to extend out--over the Main St.
sidewalk--at a right angle. My family
patronized Albanese’s, exclusively, and it was
home to my favorite arcade game, based on
bowling (but it made use of a flat puck,
rather than a ball). Bells would often be
heard--ringing up strikes and spares--and
even the occasional perfect game of 300!
More significantly, my dad considered
Albanese's crust to be more authentically
Italian.
_____Also, he liked to drink a bottle of ale
with pizza, and Johnny's--definitely more
family-friendly--just wasn’t as conducive
to that (if Johnny Bartucciotto even served
alcoholic drinks, at all). But looking back
now, I would have to say that Johnny’s
ultimately edged out its main competition.
Even our combined high school--located just
over the village line (in NT), but serving both
villages--tacitly endorsed Johnny's. It
sponsored an annual pizza party there,
awarded to the homeroom that racked up the
fewest total student absences. After all, there
WERE other pizzerias closer to school; yet the
principal bused us winners one village over,
just to be on the safe side.
_____(This photo is Bob Grossbaum's.)_____The written material on this site
has been borrowed from the book
G. Washington Slept Here:
A Sleepy Hollow Local History.
Copyright ©2021 Notary Sojak.
All Rights Reserved.
A free sample (including all of
Main St.) may be downloaded
HERE ._____Back to Home
_____55 Main St.
Drift Inn
_____(Westchester Co. Historical Society)
1976
_____
The "Drift Inn"--west of Albanese's, just
east of the "Veterans Memorial Bldg."--
is pictured (above) in its heyday. Back
in the 1960's, it was operated by Al
& Kenny Lugrezia. Later, it was run
by a Zig Scogna. Next came Tony &
Kathy, to be--still later--equalled by
(but presumably, not outdone by) the
duo of Smitty and Goldie. Then came
owners Linda Dinny Magni & Queenie
(along with their notable cream puffs).
Paul Janos, still later, added himself
to the proprietor mix (but after his
purchase of #55, the tavern's name
changed). Janos would, in time, become
Tarrytown's mayor!
_____
Today (below), the building serves dutifully
as the tax-preparing headquarters of an
accountant. The Drift Inn was a well-es-
tablished member of a set of Main Street
taverns going back to the 1950s (or, in
one case, even earlier). A tavern circuit of
sorts might be followed. This would lead
revelers from the Drift Inn to the "Set
Back Inn," then to the "Huddle," & some-
times--even to that more secluded bar--
in the back of "Arduino's Off-Broadway."
_____
Incidentally, I'm not overlooking the
"Broadway Tavern/Tim Clune's," but I
have heard that Tim's place was more
for parents, at least when it came to
drinking; as for the bar at the "Tappan
Hill Restaurant" (a bit distant, being up
on the hill, in a residential area)--the
same situation, of course--if not more so.
_____
(Google Street View.)
_____
The written material on this site
has been borrowed from the book
G. Washington Slept Here:
A Sleepy Hollow Local History.
Copyright Notary Sojak, 2021;
All Rights Reserved.
A free sample (including all of
Main St.) may be downloaded
HERE .25 Main St.
Arduino's Deli,
Bar, & Grill
_____(Westchester Co. Historical Society)
1976
_____
"Arduino's Off-Broadway Deli, Bar &
Grill" (above) still gets wistfully mentioned
by Tarrytowners from time-to-time. The
proprietors? Frank, Nick, Joe, and John
(bottom, l. to r.): the Arduino brothers. If
you look, closely, their physical arrange-
ment was hardly happenstance; notice
Nick and Joe leaning, just a bit, against
one other. Grace, their mother--as well
as Nick's wife, Margie--were also parts
of the operation.
_____
Arduino’s was a contender in the local
competition among "wedge-makers," those
who produced that sandwich referred to
elsewhere--usually--as a submarine . It
offered a so-called "Thruway" wedge, as
well as a "Parkway" version (but if some-
one were to ask me to explain the differ-
ence--between them--I wouldn’t have the
foggiest!). For those tackling an Italian
recipe at home, essential supplies were
for sale there, such as pot cheese
(which came in a tin, as below) and
ricotta .
_____
_____
This establishment used an interesting
contraction on its main sign--“B'way.” Back
then, this short-form was reportedly trendy;
furthermore, there was simply a shortage of
space on the sign. A supplemental sign--one
of a few allowed to extend out over the
Main St. sidewalk, at a right angle--con-
firmed that a bar as well as a grill were,
indeed, present there (through the deli, all
the way to the back).
_____
Additionally, there was a rather unique sign
hanging behind the lunch counter, reading:
“Village Hall South.” Perhaps the Arduino's
of local yore is best described by paraphras-
ing the theme song of that classic TV show
Cheers : "Everybody knew everybody."
__________
The written material on this site
has been borrowed from the book
G. Washington Slept Here:
A Sleepy Hollow Local History.
Copyright ©2021 Notary Sojak.
All Rights Reserved.A free sample (including all of
Main St.) may be downloadedHERE .
_____
Back to Home
To Sleepy Hollow '70s
_____
63 Main St.
Andrews Bldg.
Goldberg &
Sons Hardware
_____(Westchester Co. Historical Society)
31 Main St.
Lucky Seventh
Bodega/
Cafeteria
_____(Westchester Co. Historical Society)1976_____19 Main St.
Shubert's Army
& Navy Store
_____(Westchester Co. Historical Society)57-59 Main St.
Veterans
Memorial Bldg.
(formerly Hillcrest Theater)
(Google Street View)
_____
Like almost all of the Main St. buildings of
the 1950s, the Veterans Memorial Building of
the Tarrytowns remains standing today.
However, it would appear that the fraternal
group it hosted for years no longer makes use
of it. While I must admit that I have never
actually been inside many of the buildings
mentioned on this web page, this particular
one I know well. It was the site each spring
of a “Dads' Club” event--this group being
our local version of Little League baseball.
_____
First, we'd assemble in a bank parking lot
(just east of the start of Main St., on
Neperan Rd.). There, we’d get our shirt and
hat for whatever baseball team we would be
a part of that year. Then, a small parade
would commence, taking us down Main St. to
this building--for a pep rally, inspirational
speeches, and a raffle. (Often, a rumor
would be started--that N.Y. Yankee Mickey
Mantle would be there--in person!)
_____
Unbeknownst to us, this same facility had
once served as the "Hillcrest Theater," show-
ing silent films in the 1920s, and perhaps
"talkies" for a time after that. Reportedly,
this building has hosted a bowling alley, as
well. And no, Mr. Mantle never did show up!
_____
Annually, the author would imagine his
forthcoming chance to meet a Yankee.
_____
The written material on this site
has been borrowed from the book
G. Washington Slept Here:
A Sleepy Hollow Local History.
Copyright ©2021 Notary Sojak.
All Rights Reserved.
A free sample (including all of
Main St.) may be downloaded
HERE .23 Main St.
Galella's Barber
Shop &
Zimmer Jewelers
(formerly Headless
Horseman Book Shoppe)
35 Main St.
_____White Sea
Sea Food
(formerly Pincus
Ice Cream Parlor)
_____(Westchester Co. Historical Society)1976
_____Today's “Main Street Sweets,” 35
Main St., was yesterday's “Pincus Ice
Cream Parlor.” (During the 1970s,
after Pincus's--or Pinky’s--had
shut its doors, this building housed:
“Mesa Fabrics,”at one point; and at
another time, “White Sea Sea Food”
(as pictured above). It sounds to me
a lot like the malt shop on the old
TV show Ozzie and Harriet, only
even better! Your choice was between
a counter stool or a wooden booth in
the back--by the jukebox. Besides
Mrs. Pincus herself, workers Ethel
Katz and a Mrs. Edwards remain
well-remembered.
_____Some of the food and treats offered
there? A square hamburger (on white
bread) with a Tutti-Frutti drink in a
tall, frosted glass; not to mention a
vanilla malted milk--and the
waitress would bring you the metal
container it had just been processed
in, in case you might feel like a
refill later. Dinner items were
necessarily limited, but a revolving
menu was featured, meaning that the
same meal would always be available
on a specific day during the week;
say, meatloaf on Mondays, and so on.
_____
But this fond recall would not becomplete without a mention of
Pinky's egg creams (typically
chocolate-flavored, but with vanilla
also an option). I have to admit
that, to my best recollection, I never
got to down one of these classic
drinks, which were once popular in
New York City and environs. First of
all, its recipe doesn’t actually call
for egg. Some believe that the term
egg in its name comes from the
froth on top, which resembles
a cappuccino's foam, or--more
particularly, here--beaten egg whites.
(Others have surmised that egg cream
is simply an anglicized form of
chocolat et creme, a similar drink
served in France.)
_____While cream per se is also
unnecessary, the use of whole milk is
essential, as this is one secret behind
the creation of the froth. After
seltzer water has been added to the
milk, stirring starts the generation of
foam. Typically mixed by hand, a
long-handled spoon is required: the
syrup added last sinks to the bottom,
and it is this ingredient in particular
that requires a brisk stirring to
finish the process.
_____(Google Street View)
_____The written material on this site
has been borrowed from the book
G. Washington Slept Here:
A Sleepy Hollow Local History.
Copyright ©2021 Notary Sojak.
All Rights Reserved.
A free sample (including all of
Main St.) may be downloaded
HERE .45 Main St.
Sleepy Hollow
Antiques
(formerly McAvoy's)
_____(Westchester Co. Historical Society)1976
_____Many Tarrytowners can recall a
mom-and-pop newspaper, candy, & soft
drink store on the corner of Main and No.
Washington Sts., just west of "Alma Snape
Flowers." Today, this corner spot is occupied
by a restaurant named “Pik Nik BBQ” (see
bottom photo). In between, it hosted “Sleepy
Hollow Antiques” (pictured above). Based
on the florist being #39, I would think
that the street number for this corner shop
would be #41. However, today's tenant
goes by #45. Incidentally, this corner is
reportedly the site of the "First Baptist
Church" in the 19th century.
_____
Far fewer remember the store's exact name
in the later 1950s and then into the '60s:
"McAvoy's" (with the stress always placed on
the first syllable--MAC). I can remember
going into this shop the fall of '63 (or
perhaps the first part of 1964), wanting to
check on any new Duncan yo-yo models for
sale. But there were none to be had--only
Duncan spinning tops. If yo-yos were even
being shipped out that season, Mr. McAvoy
must have had them under the counter--or
was keeping them in the back.
_____
I had heard the Duncan TV commercial, so
I wasn't too surprised: "Put that yo-yo
away, fellas--now you can have a top--one
that whistles as it spins!" We kids were used
to being on the receiving end of a yo-yo
marketing attack annually. Then someone at
Duncan must have sensed a need for change.
Of course, now we all needed a top to spin!
While the new Duncan models were outfitted
with a plastic tip, which eventually might
need replacement, one enterprising student
somehow acquired an off-brand
“industrial-strength” top, complete with
a metal tip.
_____
Our reward? A switch back to yo-yos the
next marketing season; McAvoy's was no
doubt back to yo-yos, as well, without
missing a beat.
_____
(Google Street View)
_____The written material on this site
has been borrowed from the book
G. Washington Slept Here:
A Sleepy Hollow Local History.
Copyright ©2021 Notary Sojak.
All Rights Reserved.
A free sample (including all of
Main St.) may be downloaded
HERE ._____Back to Home
_____11-13 Main St.
Music Hall
(As seen in the 2010 movie: Henry's Crime)_____Although the design of our iconic Music
Hall theater has been credited in the past to
a Philip Edmonds, an account contemporary
to its building describes it as the work of
two other architects, the same ones who
designed the famous "Macy's Department
Store" at Herald Square in Manhattan
(presently the world's largest store). Built in
1885 of slate, brick, and terracotta, the
Music Hall is--in fact--an example of
"Queen Anne Style," which is known for
gables, turrets, and onion domes, being a
restoration of 17th century architectural
traditions.
_____The Music Hall has undoubtedly been used
as a location for feature-film shooting more
than any other spot in our villages. These
movies include (besides Henry's Crime, in
no particular order): The Preacher's Wife,
Wonderstruck, Game 6, The Impostors, The
Good Shepherd, and (with my favorite MH
interior scene) The Secret Lives of Dentists.
In the past, a few disgruntled shopkeepers
have complained about the lack of on-street
parking and similar negative consequences
whenever such a Main St. business offers
itself as a filming site.
_____Other locals report an overall positive
experience. Actor Keanu Reeves was
reportedly very low-key; seen walking around
town, buying cigarettes and a cup of coffee.
Then, without putting on "airs," the star just
hung out on Main St., apparently open to
conversation. Perhaps, some Tarrytowners
had entered the Matrix?
_____(Westchester Co. Historical Society)_____The written material on this site
has been borrowed from the book
G. Washington Slept Here:
A Sleepy Hollow Local History.
Copyright ©2021 Notary Sojak.
All Rights Reserved.
A free sample (including all of
Main St.) may be downloaded
HERE ._____Back to Home
_____
collection of my boyhood photographs of the
Tarrytowns & Sleepy Hollow'' (''my'' meaning:
those photos belonging to the Group's founding
member, known on Facebook as Andrew David).